GOSHEN, N.Y. — An Orange County man on trial for murder is facing renewed legal proceedings after a violent outburst in the courtroom last week forced a mistrial and prompted the assignment of a new defense attorney.
Arthur Thomas, who is accused in the 2020 fatal stabbing of a man in Newburgh, returned to Orange County Court in Goshen on Tuesday in shackles and under tight sheriff escort. The court appearance followed a shocking courtroom incident last Friday in which Thomas allegedly strangled his own lawyer during the trial.
The courtroom attack brought proceedings to an abrupt halt. A mistrial was declared shortly after the incident, and court officials confirmed Tuesday that Joe Artrip will now represent Thomas moving forward.
Attorney Assaulted in Front of Jury
Thomas’ former defense attorney, Matthew Witherow, who also serves as a part-time judge in the City of Port Jervis, was not seriously injured in the attack. He spoke to News 12 after the incident, stating that his commitment to his profession remains intact despite what occurred.
“I’m used to fighting for my clients on a daily basis,” Witherow said. “Notwithstanding what happened here, my commitment to these ideals is unwavering.”
The assault reportedly occurred on the second day of testimony, with one juror describing how Thomas lunged at Witherow and dragged him to the ground by the neck before court officers quickly restrained him.
New Trial and Possible New Charges
As of Tuesday, it remains unclear whether Thomas will face additional charges related to the alleged attack in the courtroom. Authorities have not confirmed if formal charges will be filed.
A new trial date is expected to be set in the coming weeks, and the case will move forward with a new jury and a new legal team.
Background on the Case
Thomas is accused in connection with a deadly stabbing in Newburgh in 2020, though details about the victim and the motive have not been released publicly due to the ongoing nature of the trial.
His case had been progressing through the court system until last week’s explosive courtroom disruption derailed the proceedings. The trial was being closely watched given the violent nature of the charges and the high-profile courtroom incident.
What’s Next
Thomas is scheduled to return to court on June 10, when court officials are expected to set a timeline for the new trial. His new attorney, Joe Artrip, has not yet issued a public comment on the case.
Officials have stated that enhanced security measures may be considered during future court sessions to prevent similar disruptions.
This article has been carefully fact-checked by our editorial team to ensure accuracy and eliminate any misleading information. We are committed to maintaining the highest standards of integrity in our content.
Vikas Lalit is an experienced content writer at OTE News, covering business, economy, and international affairs. With a degree in Journalism, he combines analytical thinking with engaging storytelling to deliver well-researched updates. Vikas is passionate about uncovering underreported stories that impact readers.
Outside of work, he enjoys playing chess, following cricket, and writing short stories. His commitment to integrity and in-depth analysis strengthens OTE News’ mission of providing trustworthy journalism.